DOES FEDERAL LAW PERMIT MALE INMATES IN WOMEN’S PRISON?

Federal law permits male inmates to be housed in women’s prisons through regulations developed under a federal statute called the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA). 34 USC Ch. 303: PRISON RAPE ELIMINATION (house.gov)

PREA was passed unanimously by the United States Congress in 2003. It had a goal of preventing, tracking and punishing prison rape. It set up a Commission to develop national Standards and provided that the federal Department of Justice (DOJ) would review the Commission’s Standards and issue Standards as a final rule.

PREA tied federal funding to State adoption of the Standards. Meaning, if a State failed to adhere to the Standards, it would face a reduction in its federal funding. This provision remains in effect.

PREA established no rules about housing or searching inmates. It established goals and left it to the Commission and DOJ to figure out national Standards.

The words “transgender” “gender identity” “gender nonconforming” and “sexual orientation” do not appear in PREA.

However, it is worth noting that the first section of PREA cites Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S. 825 (1984), a Supreme Court case which found that “deliberate indifference” to the “substantial risk of sexual assault” was a violation of the Eighth Amendment prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment. Farmer, as it happens, was a “preoperative transsexual who projects feminine characteristics.” case.pdf (justia.com) Critically, though, what was at issue in the case was not placement of Farmer into a women’s incarceration facility; he was not seeking this. (See footnote 1: “Petitioner also sought an order [to be placed] in a “co-correctional facility” (i.e., one separately housing male and female prisoners but allowing coeducational programming). Petitioner tells us, however, that the Bureau no longer operates such facilities, and petitioner apparently no longer seeks this relief.” Emphasis added.) Rather, the case was addressing the appropriate legal standard for liability under the Eighth Amendment.

The nine-member Commission to establish Standards was appointed in June 2004. Its members were appointed by then President Bush and by Congress. It included a judge, professors and several attorneys. The Commission held public hearings throughout the country and in 2009 issued a final Report and Standards. These Standards differed in several meaningful ways from the final version eventually issued by DOJ. This includes having screening tailored to females or males (whereas the final Standards are unisex), the male risk of victimization criteria was much longer (which seems to be a tacit acknowledgment that they would be housed with other males whereas women would not be housed with males). The Commission’s version also permitted limited separate housing for those at high risk of sexual victimization (such as sexual orientation, genital status or gender identity). It did not give any group the right to shower separately from others or to have their own perception of vulnerability given “serious consideration” in housing placement.

After the Commission submitted its recommendations, DOJ began its review. The review included an opportunity for public comment. Among the 600+ comments were requests that the term “transgender” be defined. DOJ noted: “The definition adopted in the final rule – “a person whose gender identity (i.e., internal sense of feeling male or female) is different from the person’s assigned sex at birth” – reflects the suggestions of numerous advocacy commenters.”

In 2012 DOJ issued a final notice of Standards and they went into effect that year. eCFR :: 28 CFR Part 115 — Prison Rape Elimination Act National Standards

Some highlights of the PREA Standards include:

• The screening process for risk of victimization and abusiveness is unisex (unlike the Commission’s recommendation, the final version has no tailoring for males or females)

• Criteria for sexual victimization risk includes, among others: disability, age, physical build, whether inmate is or perceived to be GLBTI or gender nonconforming, own perception of vulnerability

• Risk of victimization screening used to inform housing, bed, work, education and program assignments with goal of “keeping separate those inmates at high risk of being sexually victimized from those at high risk of being sexually abusive.”

• “A transgender…inmate’s own views with respect to his or her own safety shall be given serious consideration.”

• “In deciding whether to assign a transgender…inmate to a facility for male or female inmates…the agency shall consider on a case-by-case basis whether placement would ensure the inmate’s health and safety, and whether the placement would present management or security problems.” NOTE: There is no analysis about health and safety of *other* inmates. Based on the inmate’s own assessment of vulnerability and identification as “transgender,” the inmate is considered to be the one at risk of sexual abuse.

• Unlike any other category of inmate other than “intersex,” only “Transgender…inmates shall be given the opportunity to shower separately from other inmates.”

• It is impermissible to place LGBTI inmates in dedicated units based on such status, unless it is “established in connection with a consent decree, legal settlement, or legal judgment for the purpose of protecting such inmates.” NOTE: This means that a separate unit cannot be established to protect *other* inmates from those in these categories.

PREA Standards operate in all federal incarceration facilities and in all States which seek to receive full federal funding.

 

  • provide consultation submissions against proposed laws and policies which allow for cross-sex prison housing; and