ARE MALE PRISONERS REALLY IN WOMEN’S PRISONS?

YES. MALES ARE HELD IN WOMEN’S PRISONS THROUGHOUT THE UK.

The Ministry of Justice and HMPPS Policy Framework setting out when a male can be housed in a women’s prison is The Care and Management of Individuals who are Transgender. It applies to prisons throughout England and Wales.

The purpose of the Policy Framework is to:

Provide staff with clear direction in the support and safe management of transgender individuals in our care, including managing risks both to and from transgender individuals, and enabling risk to be managed when an individual is placed into a prison which is different to that of their legal gender or where a Gender Recognition Certification has been obtained.

As is common with policy documents, there is a misunderstanding of the law:

Where [transgender] individuals have gained legal recognition, they must be treated in accordance with their legally recognised gender in every respect.

In fact, both the Gender Recognition Act (2004) and the Equality Act (2010) contain specific provisions where it is legal to treat an individual with a GRC differently to members of the sex with which they identify. In short: a GRC is for most purposes, not all.

WHAT HAPPENS: MALE PRISONERS WITH A GRC

A male who has a GRC stating that he is legally a woman is initially placed in a women’s prison. Conviction, offending history and anatomy are not taken into consideration. If he poses a risk to or is at risk from the female prisoners and the risk is too high to manage in a women’s prison, his case is referred to a Transgender Complex Case Board.

Theoretically, a decision may be to transfer him to a men’s prison. However, in assessing this risk he is still ‘treated as a woman’. This means he can only be transferred to a men’s prison if that same decision would be made for a female prisoner. In practice, however, women are never held in the male estate: the risk to their safety would be too great to manage.

Treating a male prisoner with a GRC as a woman extends to risk assessment. We are repeatedly told that male prisoners are thoroughly risk assessed to ensure the safety of female offenders. However, this is not the case.

The OASys Sexual Reoffending Predictor Score, OSP for short, is used for adult men who have been convicted of sexual or sexually motivated offences. It is not for use with female sexual offenders. Neither is it used for male sexual offenders with a GRC, because these prisoners are assessed as women. There is no alternative risk assessment tool for use with women who have been convicted of sexual offences.

WHAT HAPPENS: MALE PRISONERS WITHOUT A GRC

A male who identifies as ‘transgender’ but who does not have a GRC is initially allocated to a men’s prison. If he wishes to stay there he remains there and decisions will be made about how to manage him in the male estate.

He is entitled to apply to be transferred to a women’s prison. He must provide evidence of ‘living as a woman’. His offending history, past behaviour and anatomy are also considered. The application goes before a Transgender Case Board where a decision will be made. Male prisoners without a GRC are risk assessed in the same way as all male prisoners.

When considering such cases, the Policy Framework states:

The management of individuals who are transgender… must seek to protect both the welfare and rights of the [transgender] individual and the welfare and rights of others in custody around them. These two risks must be considered fully and balanced against each other.

This paragraph is concerning. All male prisoners have the right to be safe in prison. But so do women. There are very good reasons why women in prison require a single-sex environment and why female offenders are entitled to single-sex services that exclude all male prisoners, including those with a transgender identity. The Equality Act, through the single-sex exceptions, contains provision to enable this. We do not believe that the safety, dignity and privacy of female prisoners should be ‘balanced’ against the desire of some males to be housed with them.

PRISONS IN SCOTLAND

Prisons in Scotland are covered by a different framework produced by the Scottish Prison Service: Gender Identity and Gender Reassignment Policy for those in our Custody. Published in 2014, the document is emblazoned with the logo of Scottish Trans Alliance.

The Policy Framework has a similar aim and purpose to the MoJ policy:

This policy aims to ensure that individuals who identify as transgender people or who intend to undergo, are undergoing or have undergone gender reassignment receive respect and fairness at all times from the Scottish Prison Service.

The purpose of this policy document is to: provide accurate and current information for all SPS employees in relation to gender reassignment and gender identity equality and human rights; outline the SPS procedures to be followed in the event of a transgender person being brought into custody; enable all people in custody within SPS custody to be treated fairly and without discrimination or harassment on grounds of gender identity and gender reassignment.

As with the MoJ policy, this policy also demonstrates a misunderstanding of the law. It is written as if the provision in the Equality Act (2010) that permits all males to be excluded from single-sex spaces and services for women does not exist. Second, ‘gender identity’ is included as a protected characteristic. Third, there is an attempt to include ‘gender dysphoria’ under the protected characteristic of disability. The position on housing ‘transgender’ prisoners is straightforward. Prisoners are to be housed according to their ‘social gender’:

The accommodation provided must be the one that best suits the person in custody’s needs and should reflect the gender in which the person in custody is currently living.

No distinction is made between male prisoners with a GRC and those without. Similarly, no distinction is made between male prisoners who have had ‘reassignment’ surgery and those who have not:

A male-to-female person in custody living permanently as a woman without genital surgery should be allocated to a female establishment. She should not be automatically regarded as posing a high sexual offence risk to other people in custody and should not be subject to any automatic restrictions of her association with other people in custody. However, if there is clear evidence that she, as an individual, may pose a sexual offence risk, then this should be dealt with as for any other person in custody posing a risk. Only where a risk assessment determines it is justified, should she be subject to increased staff supervision or restrictions of her association with other people in custody.

Accommodation may initially be single-cell. Whether or not a male prisoner who is ‘living as a woman’ shares accommodation with a female prisoner, is decided primarily on the basis of the risk this poses to the male prisoner. The needs of the women are secondary.

Prior to implementation of the policy an Equality Impact Assessment had been completed. In our opinion this was inadequate:

• Women in prison were not consulted, neither was any organisation representing the interests of women in prison

• By contrast, transgender prisoners, transgender people in the community and two organisations representing transgender interests, Scottish Trans Alliance and Stonewall Scotland, were consulted

• Sex was not included in the list of protected characteristics under the Equality Act (2010)

• Sex was not included in the equality groups that will be affected by the policy.

Whilst the document refers to risk assessment in respect of allocating transgender prisoners to the prison estate, the omission of the possibility of women being adversely affected leads us to question the adequacy of such risk assessment. Indeed, policy development was strongly predicated on the assumption that bringing prisoners into the female estate who would previously have been held in the male estate would not have a significant impact on female prisoners.  Instead, the policy decision-making process only treats the vulnerability of transgender prisoners as relevant.

  • provide consultation submissions against proposed laws and policies which allow for cross-sex prison housing; and