CAN A MAN BECOME A “WOMAN” UNDER THE LAW?
Obviously, “sex” in human is immutable, but can a man be recognized as a “woman” under the law?
Unlike other countries, the United States does not have national legislation which speaks to “legal sex.”
Generally speaking, there is no national identification card issued by the federal government. Obtaining federal government identification, such as a passport, has historically been based on state documents. As of June 2021, however, the State Department began issuing U.S. passports under a self-selected “gender” “even if the gender you select does not match the gender on your supporting documentation such as a birth certificate, previous passport or state ID.” Selecting your Gender Marker (state.gov)
States vary widely in their laws or policies governing changing one’s sex on government documents, such as birth certificates or driver’s licenses.
In addition to the variety of rules to obtain an identification document reflecting a different sex/gender, there is also not uniformity as to what having such identification means in every jurisdiction. Does it mean crimes committed will be recorded based on the documentation obtained to reflect “gender identity” or based on biological sex? Does it mean that for all “legal purposes” the individual is treated as is reflected on the identification? It is unclear; there is no national law on this issue. Permitting government documents to be re-issued or replaced with someone’s incorrect sex is an invitation for such documentation to be misused and abused.
In the prison housing context, assuming a male has obtained a government document with a “female” marker, it is also unclear whether this is a “pass” into a women’s prison in every jurisdiction. It certainly is for some (for example, Connecticut law provides that inmates will be presumptively housed in accordance with a birth certificate, passport or driver’s license reflecting their “gender identity”), but this is not uniform.
This broad – but varied – ability to obtain government documentation, which historically reflected “sex,” but now appears to reflect “gender identity,” and the unclear use of such documentation is an unresolved, and troubling, issue in the United States.
- provide consultation submissions against proposed laws and policies which allow for cross-sex prison housing; and






