On January 30, 2025, following President Trump issuing Executive Order “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government,” Plaintiffs “Jane Doe,” “Mary Doe,” and “Sara Doe,” three incarcerated men, filed a Complaint in federal court in Washington DC. The currently named defendants are James R. McHenry III, who was the Acting Attorney General at the time of filing, and William Lothrop, Acting Director of the Bureau of Prisons. As the names of these defendants are likely to change, for clarity, KPSS will refer to these pleadings as Moe v. Trump.
The Complaint sought an injunction to prevent the federal Bureau of Prisons from removing the plaintiffs from women’s prisons per the EO instruction to the Department of Justice. It also sought a declaratory judgment that Sections 4(a) and 4(c) of the EO (link below) violate the Plaintiffs’ rights under the Fifth and Eighth Amendments, under the Rehabilitation Act and the Administrative Procedures Act.
In court filings, the court permitted the use of pseudonyms. This is an effective way to hide from the public the nature of the crimes committed by these men.
In the Complaint, the “Does” all claim that they “may be forced to shower in full view of men who are incarcerated,” with one of these men further claiming that if he is forced to shower with men that “her breasts and female genitalia will be exposed.” Thus far, incarcerated women who raise such concerns have not been able to force these men claiming to be women out of their prisons or shower areas.
All three “Does” also claim that in a men’s facility they would “experience worsening gender dysphoria” and that such “gender dysphoria [would be] exacerbated by a lack of medical care, which can lead to serious harm, including dramatically increased rates of suicidality and depression.” Criminal men threatening suicide if they are not housed with incarcerated women – sharing their toilets, showers and sleeping quarters – should not be entertained as a serious legal argument. But, it has a history of being successful.






