On February 4, 2025, a federal district court in Washington, DC issued a Temporary Restraining Order preventing the federal Bureau of Prisons from carrying out the provisions in President Trump’s Executive Order “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government” requiring that men be removed from women’s prison.
In issuing the Order in the Plaintiffs’ favor, the Judge references their claims seemingly agreeing that mere “placement in a male penitentiary by itself will exacerbate the symptoms of their gender dysphoria, even if they are not subject to physical or sexual violence in their new facility.” He includes in the “parade of harms” claimed by Plaintiffs that they would be: “made to shower in the company of men” and that “simply because the mere homogenous presence of men will cause uncomfortable dissonance.” There has been no similar relief for incarcerated women subjected to the presence of men in their showers, toilets and sleeping quarters and no concern for the harm to women’s rehabilitation in being housed with men.
The Judge also includes in the “parade of harms” that these men would be … “referred to as men”.
He dismisses the harms to women, writing “Even if the Court credits the Executive Order’s representation that housing biological males in female penitentiaries has some deleterious effect on privacy and security, … there are only about sixteen male-to-female transgender women housed in female penitentiaries.” For this reason, he determines, “the balance of the equities and the public interest favor the plaintiffs.”
This is a stark articulation of the weight given to ideologically driven concerns for male inmates claiming to be women versus the actual rights of incarcerated women.
Men should be made safe in men’s prisons; the government has a duty to provide that. Claiming to be a woman when you are a man and threatening suicide if you are not housed with women should not be considered legitimate legal arguments providing men a ticket into women’s prison.






