NEWS

KPSS PROVIDES WRITTEN SUBMISSION ON NEW YORK SENATE BILL 2860 WHICH WOULD PRESUMPTIVELY HOUSE INMATES ACCORDING TO “GENDER IDENTITY” RATHER THAN SEX

JANUARY 26, 2023

New York Senate Bill 2860, introduced on January 25, 2023, "presumptively" houses incarcerated individuals based on "gender identity," including those who "self-identif[y] as transgender, gender nonconforming, nonbinary, or intersex."

The only way such presumptive cross-sex housing does not occur is if the person "opts out of such placement" or if "there is clear and convincing evidence that such person presents a current danger of committing gender-based violence against others." Decisions meeting this extraordinarily high burden must be made within two days and the written decision, with "a description of all evidence" supporting the decision and all supporting documentation, must be issued within four days. This is both an unreasonably high burden and an unreasonable time frame. Given this and that the Bill explicitly provides for litigation challenging the decision, with the prospect of monetary awards and attorney fees, cash-strapped correctional systems are unlikely to risk denying these cross-sex housing placements.

Additionally, the Bill expands beyond correctional facilities to extend to "other institutions" housing incarcerated individuals. Presumably, this would include forensic mental health facilities. So, this New York Senate Bill would presumptively house mentally ill incarcerated men with mentally ill women.

KPSS provided a submission to the Bill’s Sponsors and the New York State Senate Committee considering the Bill.

KPSS Submission to New York Senate on Bill 2860.pdf

  • provide consultation submissions against proposed laws and policies which allow for cross-sex prison housing; and